Turning Donor Reactivation Into Measurable ROI With Personalized Voicemail Outreach

How one faith-based nonprofit used slybroadcast ringless voicemail to reconnect with lapsed donors — without adding a single call to the team's day.

Hands of a group of people joined together in a circle

“A 684% return from one month of donor outreach.”

— Direct-response ROI, faith-based nonprofit donor reactivation campaign

Faith-Based Nonprofit

This case study features a faith-based nonprofit with a broad ministry focused on outreach, humanitarian work, and faith-based programming.

Like many nonprofits, it relies on a loyal donor base, and reconnecting with supporters who have stopped giving is critical to sustaining its mission.

The Challenge

A faith-based nonprofit wanted to reconnect with donors approaching nine months since their last gift, and those who had not given in 12 months.

Reaching these donors individually would have required approximately 130–200 calls per day. The organization wanted a practical way to encourage supporters to re-engage without relying entirely on manual outreach.

The Solution

The organization used slybroadcast ringless voicemail to deliver recorded messages from its CEO. The messages highlighted a relevant campaign and included a trackable URL.

The voicemail outreach was part of a broader campaign that also used email. Based on data-driven channel selection, donors received either two personalized voicemails or three CEO emails over the course of a month.

Combined Email and Voicemail Campaign Results

What Other Nonprofits Can Learn

Reconnecting with lapsed donors takes a thoughtful approach to timing, messaging, and outreach. By incorporating slybroadcast ringless voicemail into its donor reactivation campaign, this nonprofit added another way to reach supporters with a personal message from its CEO.

The results demonstrate the potential of combining ringless voicemail and email as part of a broader nonprofit fundraising strategy.

Hands joined together in a circle, seen from below

Use Cases

Lapsed Donor Reactivation

Reach supporters at the 9- and 12-month marks before they drift away for good.

Leadership Voice at Scale

Deliver a personal message from the CEO to every donor on the list.

Multichannel Fundraising

Pair voicemail with email and trackable URLs to measure response.

Ready to reconnect with your lapsed donors?

See what a personalized ringless voicemail campaign could do for your next fundraising push.

Log In



Thank you! If an account is found, a password reset email will be sent.

Email Address
Password

Forgot Your Password?

No problem! Enter your email address and we'll send you a reset link.


Thank you! If an account is found, a password reset email will be sent.
Email Address